|Art by John Romita Jr., Klaus Janson, and Laura Martin|
It took a while, but it has finally happened: a regular, main publishing universe Superman comic from DC actually feels like a Superman comic again.
I really wanted to like Superman at the time of the New 52 relaunch - I really wanted to like everything at the time of New 52 relaunch, for that matter, but as I've discussed in the past, (and a lot of other times in the past, at that) Superman resonates with me more than almost any other fictional character, so I was especially hoping to like the then-latest take on Big Blue - but it never clicked with me for a lot of reasons. The most obvious (and admittedly superficial) is That Costume, of course (though the "workin' man" outfit he wore in Morrison's Action Comics flashbacks wasn't much better), but in their desperate attempts to make this Superman seem fresher, they de-emphasized or outright jettisoned a lot of elements that make Superman, well, Superman.
He's not a reporter anymore, he's a crusading social blogger! He's not married to or even dating Lois Lane, he's hooking up with Wonder Woman! He's aloof, sad, and lonely, because brooding is what the marketing department seems to think is popular! He spent his early years taking on corporate fatcats, because the Occupy movement was huge in the news at the time the series was relaunched! And so on.
I understand that Superman is perceived as being a hokey concept in the ever-cynical 21st century, and that trying to make him seem hip and edgy is obviously a priority for the Greater Warner Bros. Marketing Machine, but to paraphrase the immortal words of Rocket J. Squirrel, that trick never (or at least rarely) works. We don't look to Superman to be hip, we look to Superman to be capital-G Good; anything else just doesn't feel right. All of the New 52's efforts to distance Superman from that seemed at worst a total failure, and at best they reeked of trying too hard.
Not that things were much better in the era just-preceding the reboot. The less said about that "Superman goes on walkabout through the American heartland" thing, the better.
The end result of this is that it has been so long since a regular Superman book read like a regular Superman book that the return to form by Geoff Johns, John Romita, Jr., and company feels fresher than most of the rest of DC's current output. Clark is still being written to feel like the ultimate outsider, but Johns got a lot of mileage out of that in the now-sadly-abandoned Secret Origin mini, so under his pen it feels right (and let's be honest, he is the ultimate outsider-looking-in, so that feels natural; and if I'm being honest, it appeals to the Aspy in me, making Superman more relatable that ever). But at the same time, you have Perry White all but blackmailing him to return to The Daily Planet and trying to coax him out of his shell and rejoin his traditional comic book cast/family, which is brilliantly metatextual. This Clark seems less like an aimlessly idealistic 20something, and more like the confident reporter of the past (and even at his most bumbling, Clark had to have been a great reporter to get and keep that job). Lois Lane smells a story, Jimmy Olsen has his own weird story going on in the background, Steve Lombard is a lout, Ron Troupe is the smartest guy in the room... it's the Silver, Bronze, and Chromium Age cast all mashed up and brought into the now.
And then, of course, there's the whole thing going on Ulysses, the man who thought himself to be the "last son of Earth" whose origins and powers parallel those of Superman's, and the villain who seems to be haunting them both... already very curious to see where that's going.
DC's relaunch efforts got off to a shaky start and for nearly 2 years I didn't follow any of the titles regularly. In the past year or so, though, they've been starting to win me back little by little. The Jeff Lemire / Andrea Sorrentino Green Arrow was fantastic. The first two issues of Grayson were fun reads and if #3 is just as good I think I'm in for a while. I'm really looking forward to Gotham Academy and the new Batgirl. But to like a Superman book again... if I'm being completely honest, this is the thing that I'm most excited about.
If only they could do something about that costume. No one seems to be able to make it look good. Not even John Romita SENIOR!
|Art by John Romita Sr., Klaus Janson, and Laura Martin|